I am torn between corolla s and caliber SXT. caliber has bad reports but like it. which should i go with?

hey i ve been searching for a used car and i came to a automatic caliber SXT with 15,000m and a corolla s with 30,000m. I love the caliber but the corolla defiantly has a good look and feel to it. the problem with the caliber is that it has many bad reports. is it still worth it to get it?